Welcome to our neighborhood guide series. We could not be more thrilled to embark on this journey with you as we uncover the wonders of New York City [NYC] together. Our first stop? The captivating East Flatbush is nestled in the vibrant borough of Brooklyn. The Ultimate Guide to East Flatbush
East Flatbush is a treasure trove of residential beauty, thriving amidst the bustling urban landscape. Steeped in a rich tapestry of cultures, this slice of Kings County boasts a cornucopia of local gems, from charming shops to delectable restaurants and cozy cafes to inviting libraries and tranquil parks to explore. Prepare to be captivated by the allure of East Flatbush.
This Brooklyn neighborhood is defined by its boundaries: Crown Heights and Empire Boulevard to the north, Brownsville and East 98th Street to the east, Flatlands/Canarsie and the Long Island Rail Road’s Bay Ridge Branch to the south, and Flatbush and Bedford/Nostrand Avenues to the west. It’s a dynamic enclave that beckons visitors from all directions.
Our East Flatbush Guide is your ultimate companion, whether you are a born-and-bred New Yorker, a proud resident of this illustrious city, or a soon-to-be visitor planning an unforgettable trip to the Big Apple. Within these pages, you will discover the finest places to stay, indulge in mouthwatering cuisine, and explore the captivating sights of East Flatbush.
But wait, there is more. East Flatbush is a neighborhood in flux, constantly evolving and embracing change. As new and exciting establishments continue to sprout, our guide will be right there, growing alongside this vibrant community. So, expect this treasure trove of recommendations to expand and transform, reflecting the dynamic spirit of East Flatbush.
Get ready to immerse yourself in the captivating blend of history, character, and natural beauty that East Flatbush offers. Together, let us embark on an adventure filled with unforgettable experiences and hidden gems waiting to be discovered. The stage is set, and East Flatbush is calling – are you ready to answer?
WHERE TO STAY NEAR EAST FLATBUSH
East Flatbush is a residential community, so only a few hotels are nearby. However, we are listing three hotels here that offer a great ambiance.
1. The Beekman, a Thompson Hotel
The Beekman is the perfect destination for those seeking luxury suites. The hotel has a rich history and is known for being a haven for creative minds. Nestled between two rivers, this 19th-century-designed hotel combines the best of both worlds by offering 21st-century decadence.
The Beekman is conveniently located near iconic attractions such as the Brooklyn Bridge, One World Trade Center, and the Charging Bull at Bowling Green. The hotel offers allergy-free rooms, curated interiors with a minibar, and plush beds for maximum comfort. Although pricy, the rooms and suites are pet-friendly. The hotel also boasts a restaurant by award-winning chef Tom Colicchio.
123 Nassau Street — Financial District
2. The Tillary Hotel Brooklyn
The Tillary Hotel Brooklyn offers a unique blend of old-world charm and modern amenities for an authentic New York experience. With 174 guest rooms featuring mid-century art decor, geometric motifs, elegant wooden flooring, and modish furnishings, guests can enjoy a fascinating living experience.
The hotel also features a rooftop bar and patio garden with stunning views of the city skyline, Brooklyn Bridge, and Manhattan Bridge, an on-site restaurant, and a cozy bar. Popular attractions like the Barclays Center, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and the Brooklyn Bridge are just minutes away. Guests can take a stroll through the vibrant streets of Brooklyn and explore everything the city has to offer.
85 Flatbush Avenue Extension — Downtown Brooklyn
3. Hampton Inn Brooklyn/Downtown
Picture waking up in a cozy room with floor-to-ceiling windows, showcasing the vibrant Brooklyn skyline. Located just steps from the Metro Tech Center, this 13-story gem can be found at the foot of the Manhattan Bridge. Imagine strolling down Flatbush Avenue Extension and Tillary Street, heading to a concert or game at the Barclays Center–only 20 minutes away!
No need to worry about breaking any fitness streak; their gym has it covered! And after working up an appetite, the friendly staff will serve up a scrumptious complimentary breakfast. Trust me, whether visiting for business with bigwigs like JPMorgan Chase, Goldman Sachs, Verizon, or the Bank of New York, or simply exploring the city, the Hampton Inn Brooklyn/Downtown is the perfect home away from home!
125 Flatbush Avenue Extension — Downtown Brooklyn
TWENTY BEST RESTAURANTS IN EAST FLATBUSH
1. Café Madeline
Indulge your taste buds at Café Madeline, where the savory delights are ready for you to dive into or savor from the comfort of your own home. This charming eatery is a haven for food lovers, renowned for its mouthwatering smoothie bowls and refreshing beverages. But that is not all – their extensive breakfast menu is a feast in itself.
And fear not, vegans, for Café Madeline has you covered with an array of delectable sandwiches and burgers crafted from carefully selected ingredients and an abundance of fresh veggies. With options ranging from wholesome bowls to tantalizing brekkies and catering to both vegetarian and non-vegetarian palates, choosing your meal from this tempting menu may take some time. But trust us. It will be worth the delicious deliberation.
1603 Cortelyou Road — Flatbush
2. Trini Breakfast Shed
Do not miss Trini Breakfast Shed if you love authentic Caribbean cuisine, specifically Trinidadian food. The restaurant serves flavorsome Caribbean, American, and Chinese dishes. You’ll find fried and baked foods, saltfish, roti, creole entrees, and more, along with homemade drinks. The food is prepared with an extra layer of sweet Caribbean sauce, and local flavors offer a fusion twist. Book a table or takeaway your breakfast.
3209 Church Avenue — East Flatbush
3. Lips Cafe
This tiny café serves a limited menu prepared with fresh local ingredients. It is a budget restaurant where you can have bagels, sandwiches, croissants, and porridge for breakfast. Lips Café also serves brunch every Saturday and Sunday. Visit to enjoy flavored frappes, lattes, mochas, and more.
1412 Nostrand Avenue — Flatbush
4. Milk & Honey Cafe
Milk & Honey Café is your ultimate brunch destination, offering a delightful halal coffee shop experience. Indulge in delicious coffee and breakfast options like Eggs on Croissants, Baked Salmon Salad, and Banana & Walnut Bread with Marscapone. Do not miss their healthy grain bowls, sandwiches, flatbreads, pastries, and desserts for a well-rounded and satisfying meal.
1119 Newkirk Avenue — Flatbush
5. Suede
Discover Suede for a dazzling dining adventure! Suede brings the Caribbean’s vibrant flavors to life, melding traditional ingredients with modern elegance. Indulge in exquisite dishes and specialty cocktails, reflecting the essence of the Caribbean lifestyle. Just remember the dress code: no caps, boots, sweats, athletic wear, or tank tops [for men].
5610 Clarendon Road — East Flatbush
6. CZEN Restaurant
Experience Flavorful Fusion at CZEN Restaurant. Brace yourself for a culinary adventure as Caribbean and Asian influences collide, resulting in an explosion of tantalizing flavors. Indulge in their delectable brunch offerings, available every Saturday and Sunday from 12 to 4 pm, and treat yourself to the finest seafood and fish specials on Thursdays and Fridays.
Do not forget to complement your meal with their refreshing signature drinks, ensuring a dining experience that will linger in your memory long after the last bite.
4410 Avenue H — East Flatbush, Brooklyn
7. JA Jamdown Caribbean
Do not miss JA Jamdown Caribbean! With scrumptious saltfish and butter bean, breakfast salmon, and banana porridge, this friendly spot is a must-visit. Delight in top-notch service and a warm atmosphere.
5223 Avenue D — East Flatbush
8. Vivid Caribbean American Bistro
Step into Vivid Caribbean American Bistro, a unique fusion of Caribbean and American fine dining. Savor the Vivid Pasta, Grilled Chicken Wrap, or Lobster Stuffed with Shrimp. Situated in Brooklyn’s heart, this relaxed locale offers live entertainment, brunch, and late-night drinks. An unforgettable Caribbean experience awaits!
4617 Avenue D — East Flatbush, Brooklyn
9. BKLYN PRIME
Cozy Vibes and Caribbean Delights at BKLYN PRIME. Step into a haven of warmth and charm as you embark on a culinary journey like no other. Sip on expertly crafted drinks while relishing in the flavors of Caribbean-infused dishes such as the mouthwatering Prime Pasta, the refreshing Prime Caesar Salad, or the delectable Thai Glazed Salmon with Mango Chili Sauce.
This hidden gem is not just a brunch spot; it is an immersive Caribbean experience that will transport you with every bite. From tantalizing oxtails to comforting macaroni, flavorful wings, succulent jerk chicken, and fresh fish, prepare to have your taste buds captivated.
One visit is all it takes, and you will find yourself irresistibly drawn back for more.
4315 Farragut Road — East Flatbush
10. Manchego
Visit Manchego, a Spanish-style wine and tapas haven. Immerse yourself in the inviting ambiance, and enjoy the friendly, attentive service. Explore their intriguing food and drink menu, featuring a range of Spanish wines paired with small dishes – all at reasonable prices.
1502 Cortelyou Road — Flatbush
11. Crabs In A Barrel
Dive into Crabs In A Barrel, a delightful seafood sanctuary serving up fresh and healthy dishes like mouthwatering Salmon Steak, succulent King Crab Legs, and tender Lobster Tail. Their whole snapper, porgy, crab legs, and shrimp are to die for, with every dish carefully crafted by their skilled chef. Enjoy the friendly staff and top-notch customer service, and support this outstanding Black-owned business that fries fish like no other, using a delicious batter and serving fresh veggies and rolls.
825 Flatbush Avenue — Flatbush
12. Aunts et Uncles
Next up is Aunts et Uncles, a vegan oasis offering a scrumptious menu that includes favorites like Bake & Saltfish and Mac n’ Cheese. Located in the heart of Flatbush, Brooklyn, this plant-based cafe, bar, and concept shoppe not only fits seamlessly into the tight-knit community but also helps guide it into a new era. Experience the creative fusion of delicious vegan dishes with a warm, community-focused atmosphere that makes Aunts et Uncles a unique destination for food lovers.
1407 Nostrand Avenue — Flatbush
13. G T Paradise Caribbean Cuisine
Treat yourself to G T Paradise Caribbean Cuisine, where you’ll discover a delightful menu of traditional Guyanese food paired with excellent service and budget-friendly options. Feast on their fried shark, bora, cabbage, and curry with Roti, or try their exquisite Blanjee [Eggplant and Shrimp] and Curried Fish with Mango. Everything on the menu is simply delicious, but be sure to place your order before 3 pm, as their scrumptious dishes sell out quickly. You’ll leave with a satisfied belly after savoring their superb Fish Soup.
4208 Church Avenue — East Flatbush
14. Footprints Café
Step into Footprints Café for an unparalleled Caribbean experience. As the “Home of the Rasta Pasta,” this lively spot serves up authentic Jamaican dishes for lunch and dinner, creating a vivid island atmosphere. Footprints Cafe takes pride in providing a calm, relaxed environment complemented by a friendly atmosphere and excellent service. Immerse yourself in the vibrant Caribbean vibes and enjoy a memorable dining experience.
5814 Clarendon Road — East Flatbush
15. Bake & Things
Indulge your taste buds at Bake & Things, a haven for Caribbean cuisine, Trini-style. Delight in their delicious savory crab curry, refreshing mauby, and so much more, all at fantastic prices. The enchanting flavors of their Curry Crab n’ Dumpling, Buss up Shot with Curry Goat, Sorrel Juice, Sorrel/Passion Fruit Juice, Aloe Pie, and Shark and Bake with Saltfish will have you hooked. Located on Flatbush Avenue, this little gem may have a line, but the wait is absolutely worth it for a taste of Trinidad right in Brooklyn.
184 E 35th Street — East Flatbush
16. Linda’s Restaurant and Bakery
Looking for the finest Guyanese food and pastries? Linda’s Restaurant and Bakery is your go-to spot. Enjoy the scrumptious white pudding with extra sour, delectable dahl puri, savory bake and saltfish, and irresistible pone. Linda’s is truly the number one choice for authentic Guyanese West Indian food, offering a wide variety of dishes that will leave you craving more.
5322 Church Avenue — East Flatbush
17. Los Tres Chiflados
Step into Los Tres Chiflados, a lively Mexican food haven just a stone’s throw away from Kings Theater. Adorned with minimalist rustic decor, this restaurant invites you to savor spicy, delicious Mexican dishes and professionally crafted drinks. Try their famous Chilaquiles with various sauces and sour cream, or enjoy a burger with French fries. Do not forget their special brunch menu, available from 11 am to 3 pm.
1046 Flatbush Avenue — Flatbush
18. Bamboo Walk
Experience authentic Caribbean cuisine at Bamboo Walk, where modern interiors and euphoric vibes set the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. Savor their Griot, a renowned Haitian dish featuring tender fried pork seasoned with tangy onion pickles and peppers. Whether dining alfresco in summer or indoors, guests are kindly requested to dress in semi-formal attire without hats or flip-flops.
1343 Utica Avenue — East Flatbush
19. Ital Fusion
Enjoy a full-course Caribbean fish and vegetarian treat at Ital Fusion. One of the top-rated vegetarian restaurants in Brooklyn, serving vegan and veggie dishes prepared with fresh local ingredients. Not the best place for dine-in with friends, but excellent for locals who prefer takeaways. The menu features original Trinidadian flavors.
2085 Nostrand Avenue — East Flatbush
20. Exquisite Express [Best Takeaway Caribbean-Jamaican Restaurant]
For a tantalizing Caribbean-Jamaican takeaway experience, look no further than Exquisite Express. The menu features luscious, fall-off-the-bone tender jerk
chicken, flavorsome BBQs, and fragrant curries that will leave you wanting more. Despite the small space, this restaurant is always bustling with loyal customers who can not resist the generous portions and reasonable prices. Dive into a small oxtail plate that is anything but small, and savor the taste of authentic Jamaican fast food at its finest.
2847 Church Avenue — East Flatbush
BEST PLACES TO VISIT NEAR EAST FLATBUSH
1. Wyckoff Farmhouse Museum
Begin your East Flatbush exploration at Fidler-Wyckoff House Park on Clarendon Road, where the Wyckoff Farmhouse, a National Historic Landmark, awaits. Built in the 1650s, it is NYC’s oldest preserved structure and the only surviving Colonial-style gambrel-roof house in the country.
Spread across 1.5 acres of Milton Fidler Park, the museum showcases the beautifully preserved ancient Dutch house with its remodeled kitchen, living rooms, and period furniture. It is an ideal place for children to learn about history, with a garden brimming with organic edible crops and medicinal plants and opportunities for hands-on experiences.
2. Brooklyn Terminal Market [BTM]
Just a short stroll from Fidler-Wyckoff House Park, BTM is the perfect spot for affordable shopping without compromising on quality. Before diving into your shopping spree, enjoy a delicious lunch at Suede Restaurant and savor their Caribbean cuisine. At BTM, you can find fresh vegetables, fragrant flowers, wine, spices, and many unique items. It is an excellent choice for Christmas shopping, offering an array of gifts and décor options to suit everyone’s taste.
3. Erasmus Hall
Paying homage to Dutch scholar Desiderius Erasmus, Erasmus Hall stands as NYC’s oldest learning center. Showcasing Georgian, Federal, and Gothic Revival architecture, this historic institution has evolved over the years. The original clapboard-sided, Federal-style building, constructed in 1787, continued in use and was generously donated to the public school system in 1896. The institution remains a testament to the early Dutch settlers’ dedication to education.
4. Brooklyn Center for the Performing Arts
Since its establishment in 1954, this multidisciplinary cultural center has been a hub for classic and contemporary performances at the Walt Whitman Theater. Attracting over 45,000 students from 225 Brooklyn schools annually, the institution offers arts education programs and theatrical experiences for everyone. Throughout the years, the venue has hosted a plethora of esteemed artists and groups, including the National Dance Theater Company of Jamaica, Moiseyev Dance Company, Martha Graham, Gregory Hines, Ray Charles, and Isaac Stern.
5. Paerdegat Park
Named after the marshy Paedegat Basin that flows into Jamaica Bay, Paerdegat Park is a favorite among sports enthusiasts and nature lovers alike. The park features a lush green landscape, a basketball court, a handball court, a baseball diamond, a cricket field, a children’s playground, and a refreshing spray shower. Visitors can unwind on the benches, engage in a game of chess at the checkered tables, or simply immerse themselves in the serene atmosphere.
6. Flatbush Dutch Reformed Church
Situated a mere 5 minutes from Little Caribbean, the Flatbush Dutch Reformed Church is an architectural treasure trove. The original church building was constructed around 1654 and later expanded to include a 2.5-story Federal-style stone building during the 1790s. The Gregorian tower, with its octagonal spired belfry and Tuscan colonettes, adds an air of grandeur.
The wooden-framed parsonage, a fusion of Greek Revival and Italianate styles, was built in 1853. The Colonial Revival-style church house, constructed in the early 1920s, features a striking façade made of Manhattan schist rocks and arched glass windows, completing the historic complex.
Do not pass up on the chance to explore East Flatbush, Brooklyn! From its architecture and history to its luscious parks and tantalizing restaurants, this vibrant and diverse neighborhood has endless wonders to uncover. Immerse yourself in the culture and one-of-a-kind charm of East Flatbush to discover what makes it so special. Do not let this hidden gem remain hidden any longer!
