Discover Brooklyn’s Top Ice Cream Shops in honor of National Ice Cream Month.

Feeling the heat of summer? Cool off and treat your sweet tooth with a creamy scoop [or three] of mouth-watering ice cream. And where better to indulge than the vibrant heart of Brooklyn? Even though National Ice Cream Day was yesterday, July is National Ice Cream Month, making it the ideal time to explore the top ice cream spots in the borough that you simply can not miss.

Brooklyn offers a diverse ice cream scene, from artisanal shops with innovative flavors to charming old-school parlors dishing out timeless classics and Caribbean delights. Whether you are a fan of bold, unexpected combinations or crave the comfort of traditional favorites, Brooklyn has it all. So, grab your spoon and get ready to embark on the ultimate ice cream adventure right here in Brooklyn.

Top Ice Cream Shops in Brooklyn

Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory

• Location: 14 Old Fulton Street—Brooklyn Heights
• Phone: (718) 522-5211
• Website: Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory
• Highlight: Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory’s dedication to quality and simplicity is reflected in every scoop. The historic location near the Brooklyn Bridge adds to the charm, making it a must-visit spot for anyone seeking a classic Brooklyn experience.

Pro Tips:

• Opt for the Vanilla Chocolate Chunk—it is a delightful choice layered over the Butter Pecan.
• Although the lines can be long, they move quickly, so it is worth the wait.
• Do not hesitate to ask for a sample to ensure you pick the perfect flavor.
• Once you have your ice cream, find a spot with a stunning view of the East River and Brooklyn Bridge. Enjoying your treat while watching the sunset is the ideal way to cap off a summer day in Brooklyn.

Kicking off our list of top ice cream shops in Brooklyn is a true neighborhood gem: the Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory. Since opening its doors in 2001, this beloved spot has been a favorite among locals and tourists. Offering a delightful blend of simple, satisfying ice cream and historic charm. Housed in a historic fireboat house near the iconic Brooklyn Bridge, the Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory offers a nostalgic experience that beautifully combines atmosphere and flavor.

Known for its unwavering commitment to using all-natural ingredients and handcrafting each batch, Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory ensures every scoop is a testament to quality. Their menu may be straightforward, but it features classic flavors executed to perfection. From creamy Vanilla and rich Chocolate to decadent Butter Pecan and aromatic Coffee, each option showcases the artistry of traditional ice cream making.

What truly sets Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory apart is the experience of savoring their delicious ice cream while soaking in the breathtaking views of the Brooklyn Bridge. It is a quintessential Brooklyn summer moment that leaves a lasting impression.

Opening Hours:

Sunday – Thursday: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM

Friday & Saturday: 11:30 AM – 11:00 PM

[Subject to change due to weather]

OddFellows Ice Cream Co

• Location: 44 Water Street—Dumbo|334 Furman Street, Pier 5—Brooklyn Heights|40 River Street—Williamsburg
• Phone: (718) 683-5755|(845) 495-3229|(718) 387-4676
• Website: OddFellows Ice Cream Co
• Highlight: OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is renowned for its innovative approach to ice cream, featuring a rotating selection of over 500 unique flavors. Their commitment to creativity and quality ensures an unforgettable ice cream experience every time you visit.
• Pro Tip: For the ultimate OddFellows experience, plan your visit for late Sunday afternoon when the crowds are thinner. Check their available flavors online beforehand to ensure you do not miss out on any of their unique offerings.

Next on our tour of Brooklyn’s top ice cream shops is OddFellows Ice Cream Co., a paradise for adventurous ice cream lovers. Since opening its first shop in 2013, OddFellows has become a beacon of innovation. They offer bold and daring flavors that redefine traditional ice cream. With multiple locations across Brooklyn, including Dumbo, Brooklyn Heights, and Williamsburg, OddFellows is always within reach and well worth the visit.

OddFellows Ice Cream Co. prides itself on small-batch production and a constantly evolving menu of unique flavors. Since its inception, they have crafted over 500 different flavors, each one more intriguing than the last. From whimsical creations like “Peanut Butter S’mores” [a peanut butter ice cream base with graham cracker crumbs, burnt marshmallows, and dark chocolate]. To elevated classics like “Strawberry Jam,” there is something to surprise and delight every palate.

One of the standout features of OddFellows is their dedication to offering vegan options that are as delectable as their dairy-based selections. The “Vegan Matcha Latte” is a must-try, delivering a creamy and refreshing treat that satisfies without the dairy.

Hours:

Sunday – Thursday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM

Friday – Saturday: 12:00 PM – 11:00 PM

Kith Treats

• Location: 55 Water Street—Dumbo|233 Flatbush Avenue—Park Slope|25 Kent Avenue—Williamsburg
• Phone: (347) 788-3108|(347) 889-6114|347-699-1045
• Website: Kith Treats
• Highlight: Kith Treats combines luxury and whimsy with cereal-infused ice cream and exclusive collaborations, creating an exceptional treat for every taste.
• Pro Tip: Follow Kith Treats on Instagram [@kithtreats] to stay updated on their limited-time specials and exciting pop-up collaborations, such as their recent offerings with Carissa’s Bakery featuring delectable ice cream pastries.

As we dive into our roundup of Brooklyn’s top ice cream shops, we can not overlook Kith Treats—an innovative gem that has taken the cereal-infused ice cream game to a whole new level. Created by the renowned luxury lifestyle and fashion brand Kith, this parlor is known for its unique collaborations and mouthwatering twists on classic flavors. I am personally hooked on their Strawberry [Vanilla Ice Cream Swirl] and Nutella [The Wifey by Ronnie’s Wife] creations, which offer a delightful spin on traditional favorites.

Kith Treats is not just about its signature offerings. They regularly feature exclusive, location-specific treats. For instance, the new Kith Kids store in Dumbo boasts two special ice cream blends inspired by the founder’s children, Ronnie Fieg.

The M² special includes:

Vanilla & Chocolate Ice Cream Swirl: Infused with Cocoa Puffs, Oreos, and mini M&Ms, topped with a rich chocolate drizzle.
Vanilla Ice Cream Swirl: Enhanced with strawberries, Frosted Flakes, and mini marshmallows, finished with a strawberry drizzle.

This whimsical shop is perfect for a summer outing with the kids, offering an enchanting experience with toys, books, and more.

Kith Treat Newest Collaboration + Launch

Kith Treats has unveiled an exciting collaboration with Carissa’s Bakery, offering four exclusive ice cream specials inspired by the renowned James Beard Award-winning bakery. These limited-time creations will be available at Carissa’s Bakery in East Hampton [68 Newtown Lane] through September 2nd. Expect to see these delectable treats make their way to Kith Treats locations throughout the summer, so keep an eye on their Instagram (@kithtreats) for updates on where you can find them next.

Here is a taste of what is in store:

• Hazelnut Croissant: Creamy vanilla ice cream blended with Carissa’s Hazelnut Croissant and Kariot hazelnut cream cereal, finished with a Nutella drizzle and crushed hazelnuts.
• Chocolate Chip Miso Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich: Vanilla ice cream infused with Carissa’s Chocolate Chip Miso Cookie, nestled between caramel-lined Chocolate Chip Miso Cookies, dipped in milk chocolate, and topped with Cocoa Pebbles and toasted sesame.
• Monkey Bread: Vanilla ice cream swirled with Carissa’s Monkey Bread, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, and Cocoa Pebbles, crowned with Carissa’s Salted Caramel Drizzle and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar.
• Bouchon: A decadent blend of vanilla and chocolate ice cream mixed with Carissa’s Chocolate Bouchon and Chocolate Cake Crunch, drizzled with chocolate and topped with Cocoa Puffs.

In addition to this scrumptious collaboration, Kith Treats has launched its original Ice Cream Doughnut. It is two frozen novelties shaped like classic doughnuts.

• Chocolate Doughnut: Vanilla ice cream infused with Cocoa Pebbles and chocolate-covered wafers, coated in milk chocolate, and adorned with rainbow sprinkles.
• Pink Doughnut: Vanilla ice cream blended with Fruity Pebbles, encased in a pink-white chocolate coating and finished with chocolate sprinkles.

These doughnut specials are available at all Kith Treats locations worldwide while supplies last. You can visit Kith Brooklyn, Kith Williamsburg, and the new Kith Kids in Dumbo to enjoy these limited-edition treats.

Taiyaki NYC

• Location: 294 Bedford Avenue—Williamsburg
• Website: Taiyaki NYC
• Highlight: Taiyaki NYC is renowned for its unique fish-shaped taiyaki cones, which not only look fantastic but also enhance the flavors of their premium ice cream. The matcha and hojicha flavors are particularly popular and offer a true taste of Japanese-inspired ice cream artistry.
• Pro Tip: Visit Taiyaki NYC during off-peak hours to avoid long lines and snap the perfect Instagram-worthy shots of your taiyaki cone. Share the delightful matcha and black sesame ice cream with red bean taiyaki with a friend for an unforgettable treat.

Continuing our journey through Brooklyn’s top ice cream shops, we arrive at Taiyaki NYC, where Japanese tradition meets modern ice cream artistry. Famous for their signature fish-shaped cones, known as taiyaki, Taiyaki NYC offers a unique and delightful ice cream experience. These whimsical cones are made from a waffle-like batter and filled with an array of delectable ice cream flavors, making each treat as visually stunning as it is delicious.

The taiyaki cones themselves are a visual delight, featuring golden-brown exteriors with intricate fish designs. But it is the ideal pairing of these cones with the ice cream that truly sets Taiyaki NYC apart. Popular flavors like matcha and hojicha, inspired by traditional Japanese tea, blend beautifully with the slightly sweet and chewy texture of the taiyaki cone.

Taiyaki NYC’s commitment to quality shines through in every scoop. They source the finest ingredients from socially responsible vendors, ensuring that every bite is a testament to their dedication. In addition to their signature taiyaki cones, Taiyaki NYC offers a variety of classic and innovative flavors, catering to every taste.

Taste the Tropics USA

• Location: 1839 Nostrand Avenue—Flatbush
• Phone: (718) 856-0821
• Website: Taste the Tropics
• Highlight: Taste the Tropics is renowned for its unique Caribbean-inspired flavors. Offering a taste of the islands right in the heart of Brooklyn. The “Grapenut” flavor, with its butterscotch twist, is a must-try and a nod to the shop’s long-standing tradition.
• Pro Tip: Visit Taste the Tropics in the early afternoon on weekdays to beat the crowds and savor a relaxing ice cream experience. If it is your first time, do not hesitate to ask for samples to help you choose from their delicious array of tropical flavors.

No article about ice cream in Brooklyn would be complete without mentioning one of my all-time favorite spots: Taste the Tropics. This beloved shop takes you on a flavorful journey through the Caribbean, offering ice cream flavors like soursop, guava, Irish moss, [or my favorite] a Guinness and Irish moss combination, cherry rum nut, and more. My first encounter with Taste the Tropics was over 25 years ago when I tried their “Grape-nut” flavor, a twist on the classic Grape-Nuts ice cream with a delicious addition of butterscotch.

Taste the Tropics has been a neighborhood staple since 1979 when it transitioned from a Dairy Queen, which had been in place since 1975. The shop’s inspiring history involves two brothers from Queens who transformed the Dairy Queen into a community hub catering to the Caribbean community by introducing tropical flavors over time.

Davey’s Ice Cream

• Location: 74 Meserole Avenue—Greenpoint
• Phone: (718) 609-6066
• Website: Davey’s Ice Cream
• Highlight: Davey’s Ice Cream is renowned for its commitment to using local, all-natural ingredients, resulting in rich, creamy flavors that support New York State creameries. Their “Strong Coffee” flavor, featuring Birch Coffee beans, is a local favorite.
• Pro Tip: Do not hesitate to ask for samples of the flavors you are curious about. With typically no lines, you can visit anytime and enjoy a relaxed tasting experience.

As we dive deeper into Brooklyn’s ice cream scene, Davey’s Ice Cream emerges as a must-visit destination for those craving homemade goodness. Established in 2013, Davey’s has earned a stellar reputation for its dedication to using fresh, local ingredients—and meticulous crafting of each batch of ice cream.

Davey’s unwavering commitment to sourcing all-natural milk and cream from New York State creameries sets it apart. This ensures delicious ice cream and support for the local community. This devotion to quality shines through in every spoonful, with flavors that are rich, creamy, and bursting with the natural sweetness of fresh ingredients.

Davey’s menu ranges from classic favorites like “Fresh Strawberry” and “Chocolate Chocolate” to more adventurous options like “Strong Coffee,” made with locally roasted Birch Coffee beans. Their specialty ice cream cakes are another standout, offering a decadent treat for any occasion.

Island Pops

• Location: 680 Nostrand Avenue—Crown Heights
• Phone: (347) 365-6737
• Website: Island Pops
• Highlight: Island Pops is renowned for its authentic Caribbean flavors and all-natural ingredients that transport you straight to the tropics.
• Pro Tip: Check Island Pops’ social media channels or their website regularly for updates on seasonal flavors and special promotions, as all flavors are not available year-round.

If you’re craving a tropical escape right here in Brooklyn, Island Pops is the place to be. This vibrant, colorful ice cream shop captures the essence of the Caribbean with its inventive flavors and all-natural ingredients. Island Pops is celebrated for its dedication to using fresh, tropical ingredients sourced directly from the Caribbean, making each visit a delicious adventure.

Their menu is a paradise of choices, offering everything from classic cones to refreshing popsicles. For a taste of nostalgia, try the “Grapenut” ice cream, a creamy blend of vanilla and Grape-Nuts cereal that hits the spot perfectly. If you are in the mood for something fruity and vibrant, the “Cherry Vanilla” is a refreshing choice.

Malai

• Location: 268 Smith Street—Carroll Gardens
• Phone: (347) 889-5789
• Website: Malai
• Highlight: Malai is celebrated for its rich, creamy texture and innovative South Asian-inspired flavors, making each scoop a unique and memorable experience.
• Pro Tip: Before heading over, check their menu online since they rotate 12 unique flavors every season. With new flavors every other month, there is always something fresh and exciting waiting for you.

For an extraordinary ice cream experience, Malai is a must-visit gem in Brooklyn. This unique shop offers a delicious fusion of South Asian flavors, blending traditional ingredients with innovative ice cream creations that will surprise and delight your taste buds.

Malai’s ice cream is made without eggs and churned with minimal air, giving it a luxuriously dense and creamy texture. And stands out for its rich, creamy texture and use of high-quality, locally sourced dairy. Their menu features an ever-changing selection of exotic flavors like “Golden Turmeric” and “Tamarind Spice,” making each visit a new adventure. The shop features a rotating selection of up to 12 flavors and 2 soft-serve options, so there is always something new.

Hours:

Sunday – Thursday: 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM

Friday – Saturday: 12:00 PM – 11:00 PM

Ample Hills Creamery

• Location: 623 Vanderbilt Avenue—Prospect Heights
• Phone: (347) 244-7260
• Website: Ample Hills Creamery
• Highlight: Ample Hills Creamery is renowned for its imaginative, whimsical flavors, such as the “Salted Crack Caramel” and “Peppermint Pattie,” each offering a unique and indulgent experience.
• Pro Tip: Sign up for their rewards program to earn points toward future purchases. Don’t miss the Ooey Gooey Butter Cake flavor—it is a fan favorite, and their classic vanilla is simply the best [my favorite]. To avoid disappointment, call ahead to check if your desired flavor is available, especially if you are making a special trip, as popular options can sell out quickly.

No tour of Brooklyn’s ice cream scene is complete without a visit to Ample Hills Creamery, a true icon of inventive and whimsical flavors. Since opening in 2010, Ample Hills has captivated ice cream lovers with its imaginative creations that promise a delightful journey for your taste buds.

If you thrive on creative flavor combinations and playful twists, Ample Hills is your ultimate destination. Their menu is packed with unique offerings that tantalize with every bite. The “Salted Crack Caramel” is a crowd favorite, blending the rich sweetness of caramel with a satisfying salty crunch. The “Ooey Gooey Butter Cake” delivers a decadent, dessert-like experience that mirrors the beloved cake.

One of their standout creations is the “Peppermint Pattie,” a refreshing peppermint ice cream adorned with housemade dark chocolate, chocolate flakes, and chunks of peppermint patties. It is an ideal balance of cool, creamy, and minty delight.

Hours:

Monday – Thursday: 01:00 PM – 11:00 PM

Fri: 01:00 PM – 12:00 AM

Sat: 12:00 PM – 12:00 AM

Sun: 12:00 PM – 11:00 PM

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

• Location: Multiple Locations in Brooklyn
• Phone: Multiple Contacts Numbers
• Website: Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
• Highlight: Van Leeuwen Ice Cream is celebrated for its dedication to high-quality, French-style ice cream and its impressive selection of both dairy and vegan flavors.
• Pro Tip: Do not hesitate to ask for a sample to find your perfect flavor. The knowledgeable staff are excellent at making recommendations, ensuring you will not be disappointed with your choice.

As our delicious journey through Brooklyn’s top ice cream shops continues. We can not miss Van Leeuwen Ice Cream, a cherished gem that has won the hearts and taste buds of locals and visitors. Since its inception in 2008, Van Leeuwen has evolved from a charming yellow truck on the NYC streets to a renowned ice cream phenomenon with locations across New York, California, New Jersey, Texas, and beyond.

Van Leeuwen stands out for its dedication to simple, high-quality ingredients and French-style ice cream. Each flavor is meticulously crafted to enhance the natural sweetness and complexity of its components, providing a truly exceptional experience. The shop also boasts a diverse range of vegan options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy their creamy, indulgent treats.

With several locations scattered throughout Brooklyn, Van Leeuwen is a convenient and popular choice for any ice cream lover. Whether you are drawn to classic flavors like Honeycomb and Sicilian Pistachio. Or intrigued by their inventive vegan offerings, there is always something to satisfy your cravings. And with their ever-changing selection of seasonal specials, each visit promises a new and delightful discovery.

Click here to check out all scoop shop locations.

Lady Moo-Moo

• Location: 365 Chauncey Street—Bedford-Stuyvesant
• Phone: (201) 844-9994
• Website: Lady Moo-Moo
• Highlight: Lady Moo-Moo is celebrated for its inventive flavors like “Cookies and Cowfee” and “Chocolate Vanilla Pretzel,” combined with exceptional customer service and a cozy atmosphere.
• Pro Tip: Be sure to try the irresistible Banana Pudin’ flavor and enjoy it while sitting outside for some prime people-watching.

If you are ready to venture off the beaten path, Lady Moo-Moo is a hidden haven tucked away in Bedford-Stuyvesant that deserves a spot on your ice cream itinerary. This charming parlor may not have the same widespread fame as some other Brooklyn hotspots. But it delivers with its unique flavors and exceptional quality.

Lady Moo-Moo is known for its outstanding customer service and inventive ice cream creations. The “Cookies and Cowfee” flavor is a fan favorite, blending the rich taste of coffee with chunks of cookies for a creamy, satisfying treat. Another must-try is the “Chocolate Vanilla Pretzel,” which offers a delightful mix of sweet and salty in every bite.

What truly distinguishes Lady Moo-Moo is its warm, welcoming atmosphere. The friendly staff are eager to help you explore their menu, ensuring that every visit feels like a special occasion. Whether you are a local or just passing through, Lady Moo-Moo provides the perfect setting to unwind and enjoy a delicious scoop with friends and family.

Hours:

Friday to Sunday: 2:00 PM – 8:00 PM

Gelateria Gentile

• Location: 253 Wythe Avenue—Williamsburg
• Phone: (347) 599-0646
• Website: Gelateria Gentile
• Highlight: Gelateria Gentile offers an authentic Italian gelato experience with traditional flavors like Stracciatella and Pistachio, alongside unique options like Blood Orange and Salted Caramel.
• Pro Tip: Do not leave without sampling their exquisite Italian pastries. They offer up to three samples and are eager to guide you to their latest and most popular creations.

As we conclude our exploration of Brooklyn’s top ice cream shops, we journey from the Caribbean to the charming streets of Italy with a visit to Gelateria Gentile. This authentic Italian gelateria brings a touch of la dolce vita to Brooklyn, delivering artisanal gelato that is as rich in tradition as it is in flavor. The inviting ambiance of Gelateria Gentile makes it the perfect spot to indulge in a taste of Italy without leaving the borough.

Gelateria Gentile’s story began in 1880 in a small shop in Southern Italy, where the Gentile family honed their craft and perfected their recipes over generations. Today, their commitment to quality and tradition continues in Brooklyn, where they offer an impressive range of gelato flavors made with the finest ingredients and time-honored techniques.

From timeless classics like Stracciatella and Pistachio to exciting flavors like Blood Orange and Salted Caramel, Gelateria Gentile has something to delight every palate. They also offer a tempting selection of cakes, tarts, and croissants, all crafted with the same dedication to authenticity.

Conclusion

Our Guide of Top Ice Cream Shops in Brooklyn

And there you have it—a mouthwatering tour of the top ice cream shops in Brooklyn. Whether you are craving nostalgic classics by the Brooklyn Bridge, whimsical fish-shaped cones, tropical flavors that transport you to paradise, homemade delights crafted with local ingredients, South Asian-inspired innovations, or authentic Italian gelato, Brooklyn’s ice cream scene has something to tantalize every taste bud.

Celebrate National Ice Cream Month in Brooklyn by indulging at one of our top recommended spots. Next time the sun shines bright and you are in the mood for a cool, refreshing treat, set out to explore these top ice cream shops in Brooklyn. Each spot promises a unique experience and flavors that will keep you coming back for more. So, make a plan, explore the borough, and discover your favorite ice cream spot in Brooklyn. Happy scooping!