As mid-November unfolds its charm in New York City, it offers a perfect blend of apricity—those warm winter sun rays—and the festive spirit that permeates the air. Amidst the towering skyscrapers and the bustling streets of the concrete jungle, there is an undeniable craving for the enchanting Pumpkin Spice Latte [PSL] magic that grips both seasoned New Yorkers and eager autumn visitors alike. Having traversed the captivating Autumn foliage trails, the irresistible allure of pumpkin pies in New York City takes center stage. It beckons enthusiasts to indulge in a delightful binge-eating spree.
In New York City, the bakeries cater to every palate, offering a myriad of options from traditional pinched-crust delights to avant-garde fusion creations and modern spicy twists that leave taste buds tingling.
Are you feeling overwhelmed by the plethora of choices? Fear not; we are here to guide you through the tantalizing landscape of the city’s best-preserved dessert havens. Showcasing savory pie treats that are sure to leave you yearning for more. Generous portions and mouthwatering delicacies await, enticing guests to embark on a culinary journey that warrants repeated visits.
These delectable pie havens are not confined to a single location—they pepper the cityscape, and you’ll find their tempting offerings across various parts of New York City and even beyond, throughout the United States.
As Autumn festivals and Thanksgiving approach, these delectable pies tend to vanish from shelves at an alarming rate. Stay ahead of the game by keeping a close eye on their websites and Instagram handles for the latest updates. To ensure your slice of pie paradise, do not hesitate to fill out preorder forms at the earliest opportunity. After all, in the world of pumpkin pies in New York City, time is of the essence.
Best Hotspots for Pumpkin Pies in Manhattan
1. Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffe
Indulge in the epitome of delectable delights at Veniero’s Pasticceria & Caffe, my absolute favorite haven for mouthwatering treats in the heart of New York City. When it comes to savoring the quintessential pumpkin pies on Thanksgiving, there is no rival to the timeless charm of Antonio Veniero’s historic café. A culinary gem established circa 1894. This iconic Italian establishment buzzes with activity year-round, extending a hearty welcome to guests and enveloping them in an exuberant ambiance.
Nestled within intricately carved wooden walls and beneath painted glass ceilings, Veniero’s is more than just a café. It is an experience to be shared with friends and family. The aroma of freshly brewed coffee, moist pies, and impeccably baked pastries wafts through the air, creating an irresistible allure that beckons visitors to its welcoming wooden tables.
While Veniero’s needs no introduction for its superb cup of Joe and delightful pastries, the real star of the show is the spicy pumpkin pie. It boasts a buttery crust and a lusciously creamy filling. To truly immerse yourself in the Veniero’s experience, secure your seat early and let the ambiance transport you to a world of culinary bliss. And do not resist the temptation of their seasonal autumn treats, including the divine six-inch pumpkin cheesecake. It is a true testament to the café’s commitment to culinary excellence. Join in and savor the flavors that have graced Veniero’s for over a century. And trust me, it is an experience you will not want to miss.
342 East 11th Street—East Village
2. Magnolia Bakery
No matter where you find yourself in the bustling metropolis of the Big Apple, the comforting aroma of baked goods from Magnolia is never far away. However, there is something special about this particular location. It is your go-to spot for delectable treats, conveniently nestled close to the enchanting Rockefeller Center, making it the ideal pitstop during your errands.
What began as a quaint bake shop in the West Village back in 1996 has blossomed into a culinary sensation. It is now recognized as one of the premier bakery chains in the entire USA. Magnolia has captured hearts nationwide with its irresistible offerings. From scrumptious cupcakes adorned with generous dollops of creamy goodness to captivating cakes, cookies, and their signature Magnolia banana pudding—a treat that has become a national favorite, available year-round.
Not Just for Every Day Delights
But Magnolia is not just about the everyday delights. It is a festive wonderland, especially known for its seasonal treats. From Thanksgiving pies to holiday-themed sweets and desserts that defy expectations, Magnolia elevates the art of baking to a whole new level. For a true taste of their culinary prowess, consider ordering a sampler pack that showcases their homemade delicacies, each bursting with the flavors of fresh, seasonal ingredients.
So, whether you are a local or just passing through, make this Magnolia spot near Rockefeller Center your destination. It is a place for a delightful journey through the world of heavenly baked goods. With each bite, you will discover why Magnolia has become a cherished name in the hearts of dessert enthusiasts nationwide.
1240 Avenue—Rockefeller Center
3. Dominique Ansel Bakery
Prepare your taste buds for a culinary journey to remember at Dominique Ansel Bakery. A SoHo haven that stands as the ultimate destination for delectable Thanksgiving desserts. But brace yourself for a delightful twist. Here, each treat is a unique masterpiece, promising one-off variations that redefine the art of indulgence. Take, for instance, their extra silky pumpkin pie, a marvel treated with triple-strained custard and adorned with heavenly dollops of Chantilly cream. All perched atop a crispy gingerbread crust.
Founded in 2011 by the illustrious James Beard Award-winning French pastry chef Dominique Ansel. This eponymous bakery has become synonymous with innovation and culinary excellence. Dominique skyrocketed to fame with the introduction of the Cronut. A revolutionary croissant-donut pastry that earned its place among the top 25 inventions of 2013 in Time Magazine. Now, his SoHo pastry shop continues to captivate palates with seasonal delights that push the boundaries of taste and texture.
Dive into their menu to discover a treasure trove of holiday treats. From the whimsical Chocolate Chip Cookie Shots to authentic macarons, chocolate-covered nuts, and an array of flavored sables that will leave you craving more. At Dominique Ansel Bakery, every bite tells a story of creativity, passion, and the relentless pursuit of pastry perfection. Explor the enchanting world of flavors crafted by a true maestro of sweets. It is a culinary experience you will not soon forget.
189 Spring Street—SoHo
+1 (212) 219-2773
4. Little Pie Company
In the warm embrace of Little Pie Company, every slice arrives at your table fresh and warm from the oven. Making it a quintessential gem among the best pie shops in the vibrant city of New York. Brace yourself for an unparalleled sensory experience as you delve into the aromatic spices that infuse every bite of their smooth, luscious fillings, perfectly complemented by a flaky crust.
While classics like pumpkin and apple pies are seasonal delights not to be missed. Little Pie Company beckons you to venture beyond the ordinary. Indulge your sweet tooth with the exquisite prosecco pie, the Southern pecan pie that is a true southern comfort. And the decadent Mississippi mud pie that promises to transport you to dessert heaven. But for a savory twist, do not overlook their piping hot chicken pot pie, a savory masterpiece that deserves a place on your culinary checklist.
Whether you prefer to savor a hefty ten-inch slice paired with a velvety latte or opt for a sampler pack featuring five-inch pieces [four slices] to take home, Little Pie Company ensures that your cravings are met with gusto. And for those with dietary considerations, rejoice. This is the place to relish a fair share of gluten-free pies and cupcakes. Even if you are watching your sugar intake, fear not, as they serve up delicious sugarless apple pies that cater to every palate and dietary preference.
Embark on a delightful journey of flavors and textures at Little Pie Company, where each creation is a testament to culinary craftsmanship. It is not just a pie. But an experience crafted to satisfy your cravings and elevate your dessert game to new heights.
424 West 43 Street —Theater District
5. The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory [CICF]
Elevate your Thanksgiving dessert with a visit to The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory [CICF]. It is your ultimate destination for a delightful fusion of frozen treats and irresistible cakes. Whether you are seeking the perfect accompaniment for a family gathering or a delightful surprise for your guests, CICF has you covered. Picture succulent frozen desserts, crafted with love, served in charming waffle cones, M&M cookie cones, cups, and glasses. A feast for the eyes and the taste buds.
This is not just any ice cream parlor—it is a family-run establishment that has been enchanting taste buds with its homemade delicacies since 1978. Beyond the traditional offerings, CICF takes ice cream to new heights, presenting exotic pie flavors that tantalize your senses throughout the year. And for those in the mood for something truly indulgent. Their towering cakes adorned with ice cream ganache are a must-try, especially if you happen to be in the vicinity.
Step into this culinary haven in the heart of Chinatown. It is where humble portions meet an expansive menu, featuring standout varieties that cater to every craving. The welcoming staff adds an extra layer of warmth to the experience, making every visit a delightful affair. So, why settle for ordinary desserts when you can embrace the extraordinary at The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory? Come for the ice cream, stay for the cakes, and leave with memories of a dessert experience that transcends the ordinary.
65 Bayard Street—Lower East Side
(212) 608-4170|757) 752-8696
6. Milk Bar
Step into the whimsical world of Milk Bar, where unexpected and flavor-packed sweet treats take center stage in the bustling landscape of New York City. Founded in 2008 by the renowned James Beard award-winning pastry chef, Christina Tosi, Milk Bar has become a beacon of culinary creativity and indulgence.
As the Autumn breeze returns, so do the towering delights at Milk Bar. Brace yourself for the return of Christina Tosi’s Pumpkin Coffee Cake, a decadent tower of fall flavors, and the 2-in-1 gooey Pumpkin Milk Bar Pie. This seasonal sensation unveils a twist of ingredients, presenting a fusion of the quaint pie experience laid on a sumptuously buttery pecan crust. And let us not forget the pièce de résistance—the Milk Bar pie itself. A cereal-crusted soft-serve filling, dusted with a sprinkle of powdered sugar.
The Autumn sweets and Thanksgiving specials are flying off the shelves at Milk Bar, whether you are on a thrilling in-store hunt or opting for the convenience of online shopping. Dive into the festive spirit by exploring their bundled sweets and truffle packs, perfect for the little ones with a sweet tooth. These artisanal boxes are not just desserts. They are incredible gifts that add a touch of magic to any occasion.
Milk Bar is more than just a bakery. It celebrates bold flavors, creative confections, and the joy of indulging in the unexpected. Join the ranks of those savoring the extraordinary at Milk Bar. It is where every bite is a testament to the artistry of Christina Tosi and a journey into the world of uniquely crafted sweet delights.
246 Mott Street—Nolita
7. Lady M Cake Boutique
As October unfolds its magic at Lady M Cake Boutique—a cozy haven that beckons crowds with its unique creation, the sui generis pumpkin nuage. This extraordinary pie and cheesecake fusion boasts a delicate and airy crust of graham crackers. It is generously topped with a layer of creamy cheese that dances on your palate with a subtle hint of cinnamon. A sensation you will not find anywhere else.
Embracing the festive spirit, Lady M unveils limited edition packages every year. But be forewarned—these delectable offerings tend to vanish from the shelves at lightning speed. Despite the overwhelming demand, the boutique remains a haven of indulgence, consistently churning out freshly baked cakes, mille crepes, and biscuits to satiate even the most discerning taste buds.
Step into the small boutique with pristine white interiors, a serene oasis where you can relish your favorite pastry or perhaps snag a walloping nine-inch cake for an upcoming event. Lady M Cake Boutique is not just about desserts. It is an experience that combines artistry, flavor, and a touch of elegance. Do not miss the chance to treat yourself to the extraordinary. Where every bite is a celebration and every visit is a journey into the world of exquisitely crafted confections.
8. Breads Bakery
Discover the unparalleled freshness and top-notch food quality that has garnered Breads Bakery an enormous and devoted following across all its locations. Renowned as the home of the best chocolate babka in New York, this establishment has become a seasonal go-to for locals seeking exclusive offerings, especially during the pie galore of each passing year.
Breads Bakery takes pride in producing baked goods in small batches, ensuring visitors are treated to a continuous stream of freshness throughout the day. Look no further than their shops for the city’s finest challahs. Each braided sesame delight practically compels you to keep coming back for more. Do not miss the chance to explore their breakfast menu, featuring healthy granola and fresh fruit servings that elevate your morning routine.
For those eager to dive into the culinary wonders of Breads Bakery, their website is a treasure trove of knowledge. Uncover the secrets of their recipes, from detailed ingredient information to step-by-step instructions and even a storage guide. It is a comprehensive resource that invites you to master the art of their exceptional creations. This ensures the Breads Bakery experience extends beyond the storefront and into your own kitchen. Join the legion of enthusiasts who have unlocked the secrets of Breads Bakery’s success and indulge in a world of extraordinary flavors and culinary delights.
18 E 16th Street—Union Square
Best Pumpkin Pies in Brooklyn
9. Marthas Country Baking
Craving the best classic pumpkin pie in Brooklyn? Look no further than Marthas Country Baking, where authenticity meets indulgence in every flavorful bite. Freshly baked on-site, their pies are a symphony of consistency, taste, and generous portions—all crafted with gourmet ingredients. Picture the soft, juicy pumpkin perfectly spread over a thick golden crust, served with an irresistibly delicious blob of cream. It is a culinary journey that promises to delight your taste buds.
But Marthas Country Baking is not just about pies. It is a haven for early risers in search of the perfect morning brew. From 6 AM to 12 AM daily, indulge in their fresh offerings that go beyond the ordinary. Chewy cookies, fruit tarts, pastries, muffins, cannoli, cheesecakes, mousses, and much more, all waiting to be paired with your favorite espresso or a comforting cup of hot chocolate. With ample indoor and outdoor seating, it is the perfect spot to grab a seat, unwind, and relish an array of munchies that cater to every palate.
Do not settle for the ordinary when you can experience the extraordinary at Marthas Country Baking. Join the community of enthusiasts who have discovered the joy of savoring delectable treats in a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you are a pumpkin pie lover or a morning coffee enthusiast, this is where flavors come alive, and every visit is a culinary adventure.
263 Bedford Avenue—Williamsburg
Prepare your taste buds for an ethereal experience at Baked, heralded as one of the premier destinations for seasonal pies in Red Hook. As Thanksgiving approaches, Baked is in full swing, ready to elevate your festivities with a touch of tradition and a dash of innovation. Renowned as the borough’s famous brownie makers, they consistently deliver toothsome dessert spreads, crunchy granolas, irresistible donuts, and stunning wedding cakes throughout the year.
Among their recent Thanksgiving specials, the Chocolate Bourbon Pecan has emerged as a neighborhood favorite. It captures hearts with its rich and indulgent flavors. Yet, the indulgence does not stop there—Baked offers a tantalizing array of options to suit every palate. Consider the chocolate cranberry chess pie or the classic cinnamon apple pie. Both are worthy additions to the store’s menu, promising a delightful journey through seasonal flavors.
Step into Baked and immerse yourself in a world where every bite is a celebration of culinary craftsmanship. Join the community of enthusiasts who have made Baked their go-to spot for delectable treats, and let your taste buds revel in the extraordinary. With each seasonal creation, Baked invites you to savor the essence of tradition while embracing the excitement of culinary innovation. It s not just a bakery—it is an experience that transforms ordinary moments into extraordinary memories.
359 Van Brunt Street—Red Hook
(718) 222-0345 ext. 1
11. Junior’s Restaurant & Bakery
Indulge in the epitome of Thanksgiving decadence at Junior’s Restaurant & Bakery. It is where the most delectable pumpkin cheesecakes take center stage on your holiday feast. Firmly set on a graham crust, these culinary masterpieces boast a thick layer of classic pie goodness coupled with generous lashings of pumpkin buttercream beneath the velvety cheesecake. Each bite is a celebration of smooth buttercream infused with the rich essence of cinnamon and nutmeg. It is a symphony of flavors that will leave you craving more.
At Junior’s, they do not just create cheesecakes. They are renowned for crafting the ‘World’s Most Fabulous Cheesecake.’ Step into this spacious restaurant, where impressive vibes mingle with stretchy seating arrangements, creating the perfect ambiance for a Thanksgiving feast with family and friends. Whether you are a longtime fan of their iconic desserts or a newcomer eager to experience culinary excellence. Junior’s invites you to savor every moment and every bite in an environment that exudes warmth and hospitality.
If you are a cheesecake lover make Junior’s your destination for indulgence and celebration. As you gather around the table with loved ones, let the tantalizing aroma of pumpkin cheesecake and the inviting atmosphere of Junior’s Restaurant & Bakery elevate your Thanksgiving experience to new heights. It is not just a meal—it is a culinary journey that leaves a lasting impression on your taste buds and your heart.
386 Flatbush Avenue Ext.—Downtown Brooklyn
12. Four and Twenty Blackbirds
Embark on a journey into the world of pie perfection at Four and Twenty Blackbirds—a haven dedicated solely to the art of pie making. Founded in 2009 by the talented Elsen sisters, Melissa and Emily, this family-run bakery in Brooklyn has established itself as the unrivaled purveyor of the city’s finest pies. The pies are meticulously crafted from seasonal ingredients sourced with care from local orchards. Their dedication to the craft earned them the prestigious title of ‘Artisans of the Year’ by Time Out New York within two years of entering the business.
For those with a penchant for the tangy side, the pumpkin pies at Four and Twenty Blackbirds are an absolute delight. Each bite unveils a symphony of flavors—a piquant filling on a flaky base, featuring aromatic richness derived from the perfect blend of brown butter, pumpkin, lemon juice, and spices.
The menu at this pie haven is a testament to their commitment to culinary excellence. They feature the finest selections, like matcha custard, black bottom oats, and more. However, the chocolate pecan pies steal the spotlight, presenting rich bittersweet delicacies that never fail to wow guests at any event.
As the preorder availability swiftly dwindles at their Brooklyn store, those lucky enough to arrive early still stand a chance to snag a pack from the limited offerings—available only on a first-come, first-served basis. So, set your alarm, be an early bird, and ensure you do not miss the chance to savor the extraordinary pies that have made Four and Twenty Blackbirds a beacon of pie perfection in the heart of Brooklyn.
439 3rd Avenue—Gowanus
13. Pie Corps
Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, Pie Corps stands as a testament to the artistry of pie-making, offering a unique experience in a city teeming with culinary diversity. Beyond being appreciated for its quality offerings, this pie-only haven draws crowds for its offbeat and innovative creations. From thoughtful brown butter crumb toppings to the surprising inclusion of key limes in buttery cookie crusts. Pie Corps consistently embraces culinary innovations that elevate the pie experience to new heights.
For those seeking a feast day surprise, the decadent chocolate maple pecan pie at Pie Corps is a crowd-pleaser, especially among the younger audience. Featuring a luscious combination of a thick chocolate bottom and an upper layer of maple pecan filling. It is a delightful indulgence that captures the essence of celebration.
However, the true star on Pie Corps’ menu is their bestseller, the Brown Butter Pumpkin Pie—a handmade delight with a spicy blend and a topping of irresistible brown butter crumbs. It is a culinary masterpiece that encapsulates the season’s essence in every bite.
And for those with dietary preferences, Pie Corps has a thoughtful solution. Enter their Vegan Brown Sugar Pumpkin Pie—a delectable creation designed for those on a plant-based diet, ensuring that everyone can partake in the joy of indulging in a scrumptious pumpkin pie.
Step into Pie Corps, where every pie is a work of art, and innovation knows no bounds. Join those who appreciate the extraordinary and savor the flavors that have made this Brooklyn gem a standout in the world of pies.
77 Driggs Avenue—Greenpoint
14. Mia’s A Brooklyn Bakery
Elevate your theme party to a whole new level with a custom cake from Mia’s Brooklyn Bakery—the pièce de résistance that will undoubtedly steal the show as it graces the center table. Whether it’s a whimsical celebration or an elegant affair, Mia’s has the artistry and expertise to infuse your event with the perfect touch of sweetness. From the crack of dawn until midnight, this bakery serves up not just cakes but a delightful array of cream coffee, pastries, and more, ensuring your cravings are satisfied at any hour.
But Mia’s isn’t just about cakes; it’s the go-to destination for the best fruity pies with amazing frosting in the entirety of NYC. These gorgeous pies aren’t merely decorative; they’re a flavorful experience that adds a touch of glamor to your Thanksgiving dinner table. Indulge in the most ostentatious pies, meticulously crafted to delight even the most discerning taste buds.
And if you find yourself in the mood for a celebration, Mia’s gallery is a treasure trove of delights. Dive into a world of cake pops, cupcakes, and other treats that promise to infuse your banquet with fun and flavor. Mia’s Brooklyn Bakery isn’t just a place to satisfy your sweet tooth; it’s a destination for creating memorable moments and turning ordinary gatherings into extraordinary celebrations. Join the festivities and let Mia’s delectable creations become the centerpiece of your next event.
139 Smith Street—Bay Ridge
15. Pies ‘n’ Thighs
Satisfy your cravings for both sweet and salty delights under one roof at Pies ‘n’ Thighs, a haven of Southern specialties that promises a culinary experience like no other. This establishment boasts a menu adorned with multiple award-winning items. Each a masterpiece in its own right—fried chicken, apple pie, chicken biscuit, and more. Amidst the tempting choices, it is hard to resist the allure of their banana cream pie and Sarah’s Concord grape jelly, both deserving of a special place in your culinary adventure.
The story of Pies ‘n’ Thighs reads like a fairy tale saga for founders Sarah Sanneh and Carolyn Bane. Their journey began as cooks at a stalwart Diner and in 2006, they transformed a beer storage closet near the Williamsburg Bridge into their culinary haven. In this miniature kitchen, equipped with merely six stools, they crafted sizeable donuts, pork sandwiches, and crispy fried chicken that quickly garnered a dedicated following. By 2010, Sarah and Carolyn found themselves in a sunlit corner with a spacious new location—a testament to the success and growth of their culinary dreams.
As you step into Pies ‘n’ Thighs, you are not just entering a restaurant. You are immersing yourself in a tale of passion, dedication, and delicious triumphs. Join the community of enthusiasts who have made Pies ‘n’ Thighs a destination for Southern comfort and culinary excellence. From fried chicken that is a work of art to pies that transport you to dessert heaven. This is more than a meal. It is a celebration of flavor, history, and the joy of sharing exceptional food with good company.
166 S 4th Street—Williamsburg Bridge
Craving for the Best Pumpkin Pies in New York City
Indulge your pumpkin pie cravings in the heart of the city that never sleeps—New York City. The quest for the Best Pumpkin Pies in New York City takes you on a journey through the rich tapestry of American pie-making. It is where fruity, nutty, and veggie editions vie for your attention. Thankfully, when the desire for a delectable pumpkin pie strikes, the city’s best bakeries and cafes stand ready to rescue you from the messy kitchen chores.
Your bright orange delight awaits—just a few clicks away. Explore the curated dessert menus on the store websites or apps. And with a swift order, your perfect pumpkin pie in New York City will be on its way. However, act quickly, for the holiday orders are flying off the virtual shelves, and you would not want to miss out on these seasonal delights.
Feel free to order extra chunks, embracing the spirit of intuitive eating during the holidays. And on Turkey Day, you are more than excused for savoring a few extra slices. So, let the aroma of pumpkin spice guide you to the best pumpkin pie experiences the city has to offer—because when it comes to pumpkin pies in New York City, every bite is a celebration of flavor and tradition.